Direct answer
Review your group benefits every year, but don't assume you should move every year. A yearly review means reading the renewal, understanding why the price changed, and checking the plan still fits your team. Going to market (getting quotes from other insurers) makes sense when the increase is hard to explain, service is poor, or your team has changed. Actually switching carriers can bring disruption, such as new claim rules, re-enrolment, and changes in how existing conditions or ongoing claims are handled, so move only when the gain is clearly worth it. Your broker or advisor can help you decide which step fits this year.
Review, market, or move: three different things
People often say "shop the plan" when they mean one of three very different steps. Separating them makes the yearly decision much calmer.
| Step | What it means | Effort and disruption | When it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| **Review** | Read the renewal, ask why the price changed, check the plan still fits your team | Low. Nothing changes for employees unless you decide to change it | Every year, at every renewal |
| **Market** | Your broker or advisor asks other insurers for quotes on a similar plan | Medium. Needs census and claims information and time before the renewal date | When the increase is hard to explain, service has slipped, the team has changed, or it's been several years since anyone checked |
| **Move** | You switch to a new insurer or a new structure | Higher. New booklets, cards, enrolment, and claim rules, plus a transition to manage | When the alternative is clearly better on price, coverage, or service, after weighing the disruption |
A yearly review is just good housekeeping. Marketing the plan is a tool you use when the review raises real questions. Moving is a decision, not a habit.
Why moving every year isn't automatically the smart play
Switching carriers isn't free, even when the new premium is lower. Things to weigh with your advisor:
- **Employee disruption.** New cards, new booklets, new enrolment, and sometimes a new claims app or pharmacy setup. People notice.
- **Rules that can change on a switch.** Depending on the contracts, a new insurer may handle waiting periods, ongoing claims, disability claims already in progress, or existing conditions differently. Ask how each one transfers before you sign. See How to switch group benefits providers without a coverage gap.
- **First-year pricing.** A new quote is a starting point. Ask what the next renewal could look like, and whether any rate guarantee applies. See What is a rate guarantee on group benefits, and should I ask for one?.
- **Balances and pending claims.** Find out what happens to claims in progress and any unused amounts when the old plan ends. See What happens to unused balances and pending claims when you switch plans?.
- **Admin time.** Someone on your side has to manage the switch, the employee communication, and the cleanup.
Why never checking the market isn't smart either
The opposite habit, signing every renewal without a look, has its own costs:
- **You lose your reference point.** Without a comparison, it's hard to tell whether an increase is reasonable or just the insurer's opening number.
- **Your team changes faster than your plan.** New hires, people leaving, or a growing team can make the original design a poor fit.
- **Your options change.** New structures, like pairing insurance for bigger risks with an employer-funded health account for everyday care, may not have existed or been on your radar when you first set the plan up.
A credible alternative also helps your renewal conversation. See How to negotiate a group benefits renewal in Canada.
A simple decision guide for this year's renewal
Start with a review. Then use these questions to decide whether to go further.
- **Can you explain the increase?** If your advisor can walk you through it (claims, trend, pooling, plan changes) and it makes sense, a review may be enough. If not, consider marketing the plan. Background: How do I read a group benefits renewal?.
- **Is service working?** Slow claims, confused employees, or unanswered questions are good reasons to look around, even if the price is fine.
- **Has your team changed?** A different size, mix of ages, or set of needs since the plan was designed points to at least a redesign conversation.
- **When did someone last check the market?** If it's been several years, a market check gives you a current reference point, even if you stay.
- **Is there a clearly better option?** Move only if the alternative wins on price, coverage, or service after you count the switching disruption.
- **Do you have time?** Marketing and moving take time before the renewal date. See When should Canadian small businesses start shopping benefits before renewal?.
If the answer is "stay, but change something," you may not need a new carrier at all. A redesign with your current insurer, or a mid-year change where the contract allows it, can be enough. See Can I switch group benefits plans mid-year in Canada?.
The fair broker view
A good broker or advisor isn't the obstacle here. They're usually the person who does the marketing work, knows how different insurers handle transitions, and can tell you when a lower quote hides a weaker plan. Some advisors market a plan on a regular rhythm; others prefer to market only when there's a reason. Either approach can be fine. What matters is that you understand why you're staying or moving, and that the decision is made with the full picture, not just the first-year premium.
Questions worth asking: 10 questions to ask your broker before you accept a benefits renewal.
Another option: change the structure, not just the carrier
Some small businesses use the yearly review to rethink the structure instead of comparing like-for-like quotes. One common approach is a hybrid: keep insurance for bigger risks, and fund everyday care through an employer-funded account.
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Because everyday care is funded with set amounts you choose, that part of the cost is more predictable from year to year. It doesn't replace insurance for bigger risks, and it works alongside your broker or advisor. See Insurance for big risks, an HTA for everyday care.
For what counts as an eligible medical expense, use the CRA's list of eligible medical expenses. For employer health account rules, start with the CRA's guidance on health plans as employee benefits and What CRA rules apply to employer health accounts in Canada?.
Checklist: your yearly benefits review
- Renewal received and read, with a breakdown by benefit line
- Asked your advisor to explain what drove the change (claims, trend, pooling, plan changes)
- Checked whether the plan still fits your team's size and needs
- Noted any service problems employees have raised
- Decided: review only, market the plan, or move, and written down why
- If marketing: started early enough to compare before the renewal date
- If moving: confirmed how waiting periods, ongoing claims, and existing conditions transfer
- Asked what the second-year renewal could look like, not just the first-year price (and whether a rate guarantee applies)
- Considered at least one alternative structure (for example, insurance plus an HTA)
- Planned how you'll explain any changes to employees
About Zemma
Zemma is a benefits platform for Canadian solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time benefits buyers. Zemma's Health Trust Account (HTA) funds everyday care with balances that carry forward. Optional coverage can sit alongside when you need it.
Who this is for
- Owners and office managers wondering if they should "shop" benefits every renewal
- Small businesses deciding whether this year is a review year, a market year, or a move year
- Teams with a broker who want a calm, broker-friendly decision frame
- Accountants and advisors who need a plain-English shareable on yearly shopping habits
FAQ
Should I shop my group benefits every year?
Review them every year, but don't assume you should move every year. Market the plan when the increase is hard to explain, service is poor, or your team has changed, and switch only when the alternative is clearly better after counting the disruption.
Is it bad to switch group benefits carriers often?
It isn't automatically bad, but each switch brings disruption: new cards and enrolment, and possible changes in how waiting periods, ongoing claims, and existing conditions are handled. Frequent moves only pay off if each one is clearly worth it.
How often should a small business market its group benefits?
There's no single rule. Some advisors market on a regular rhythm, others only when there's a reason. A good trigger is an increase you can't explain, poor service, a changed team, or several years without a market check.
What's the difference between reviewing and marketing a plan?
A review means reading your renewal and checking the plan still fits. Marketing means your broker or advisor asks other insurers for quotes. You can review every year without marketing every year.
Can I change my plan without changing insurers?
Often, yes. Plan design changes with your current insurer, or adding an employer-funded health account for everyday care, can address cost or fit without a carrier switch. Check your contract and talk to your advisor.
What is a Health Trust Account (HTA)?
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Bring this guide to your broker or advisor and decide together whether this is a review year, a market year, or a move year. If you'd like to see how an HTA for everyday care could sit next to the insurance you keep for bigger risks, book a 20-minute intro with Richard, or take a look at zemma.ca. We work alongside brokers and accountants.
Related questions
- How to negotiate a group benefits renewal in Canada
- What is a rate guarantee on group benefits, and should I ask for one?
- When should Canadian small businesses start shopping benefits before renewal?
- How do I read a group benefits renewal?
- 10 questions to ask your broker before you accept a benefits renewal
- Can I switch group benefits plans mid-year in Canada?
- How to switch group benefits providers without a coverage gap
- What happens to unused balances and pending claims when you switch benefits plans?
- Insurance for big risks, an HTA for everyday care: how a hybrid benefits setup works
- What is a Health Trust Account (HTA) in Canada?
- What CRA rules apply to employer health accounts in Canada?
- Why did our benefits go up when nobody used the plan?
- How to tell employees about benefits changes at renewal (with a template)
Not legal, tax, or insurance advice. How waiting periods, ongoing claims, and existing conditions are handled on a switch depends on the insurers and contracts involved. Confirm every detail with your broker and accountant. Last updated: Nov 16, 2026. Last updated: Nov 16, 2026.