FAQ

Is a 15% (or 20%+) benefits renewal increase normal?

Updated Oct 21, 2026

Direct answer

It can happen, especially in small plans, but it's well above what Canadian industry outlooks expect for 2026 (roughly 7–10% overall), so don't accept it blind. A 15% or 20%+ jump usually means something specific moved: a large claim, a change in who's on the plan, pooling or trend charges, or plan design. Ask for the full renewal report, have your advisor explain each driver, compare options, and decide before the deadline.

*Figures last reviewed: Oct 21, 2026. Industry outlooks are re-checked quarterly.*

The short version: possible, not automatic

A 15% or 20%+ renewal increase isn't proof that anything went wrong. Small group plans don't get the smoothing that big plans get, so one year can swing a lot. But a number that far above the published outlooks is a reason to ask questions, not a reason to sign.

The goal of this guide is simple: help you work out *why* your number is what it is, and what you can do in the time you have before the renewal deadline.

Zemma is a benefits platform for Canadian solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time benefits buyers. We're broker-friendly. A big renewal is usually a conversation to have *with* your broker or advisor, not around them.

How your number compares to the 2026 outlooks

There's no official "normal" renewal figure in Canada. The closest benchmarks are industry outlooks, which measure slightly different things:

Source (date)What it measures2026 figureNotes
ZLC Employee Benefits Solutions, via CPABC (Dec 9, 2025)Total employee benefits plan inflation**About 7%** projectedRecommends a **5–10%** assumption for multi-year planning. Its 2025 projection was about 6%.
BBD outlook, shared by Schueler Group Benefits (BBD Dec 9, 2025; Schueler Jan 13, 2026)Group benefit costs**8–10%**"Most sources agree that benefit costs could rise between 8% – 10%."
Aon 2026 Global Medical Trend Rates, via Canadian HR Reporter (2026)**Medical trend** for Canada (the projected increase in the cost of medical care per person)**8.3%** gross (up from 7.4% in 2025)Medical trend isn't the same as your total premium increase. It's one input insurers use.

These are outlooks, not quotes. A small plan can land well above or below them. For the full breakdown by benefit line, see How much do group benefits go up each year in Canada?.

So if your renewal says 15%, the question isn't "is this allowed?" It's "what's the gap between the market outlook and my number made of?"

What makes a big jump more likely

Pooled vs experience-rated pricing gets its own guide: Pooled vs experience-rated benefits: why one claim can move a small plan's renewal. The short version: the more your price depends on your own claims, the more one bad year can show up in your renewal.

DriverWhat it meansWhat to ask
Large claimOne expensive drug, hospital, or disability claim can move a small plan a lotHow much of it is pooled vs left in our experience?
Experience ratingYour own claims history is a bigger share of next year's priceWhat % of our rate is experience vs manual/pool?
Pooling chargesThe fee for protection against very large claims can rise on its ownWhat pooling charge and threshold did the insurer use?
Trend assumptionsInsurer expectations for medical, dental, and disability cost growthWhat trend % was applied to each benefit line?
Who's on the planHires, departures, ages, and new dependants change the mix fast in a tiny teamHow much of the increase is census vs claims vs trend?
Plan design changesHigher maximums, new coverage, lower co-pays, added paramedicalWhich design changes this year show up as cost?
Admin / retention chargesFees that can move independently of claimsWhere do admin and retention show on the full report?

A 15% or 20%+ letter without that breakdown is incomplete. The letter shows the new rate. The report shows why.

A 5-step response to a big renewal

  1. **Ask for the full renewal report, not just the letter.** The letter shows the new rate. The report shows claims experience, pooling, trend, and admin charges, which is where the explanation lives. A plain-English walkthrough of how to read it is coming soon (`how-to-read-group-benefits-renewal-canada`, RN-07).
  2. **Understand the pooling.** Ask how large claims are treated: what's pooled across the insurer's wider block and what stays in your experience. A one-time claim that's mostly pooled should affect you differently than ongoing claims.
  3. **Ask your advisor for options.** That can mean negotiating the renewal, adjusting plan design, or marketing the plan to other insurers. See How to negotiate a group benefits renewal in Canada.
  4. **Compare structure, not just price.** If the increase is driven by everyday care that's predictable year to year, it may be worth asking whether that part needs to sit inside insured coverage at all. More on that below.
  5. **Decide before the deadline.** Plans renewing January 1 often get their renewal package in October or November. If the timeline is tight, see How do I avoid the benefits renewal hostage situation in Canada? and Can I switch group benefits plans mid-year in Canada?.

When a big increase is a signal to restructure

A single large increase after a one-time claim may settle down. A pattern is different. It may be time to look at the structure of your plan, not just this year's number, if:

  • You've had above-market increases for more than one renewal in a row.
  • Most of your cost is everyday care (dental, physio, glasses, prescriptions) that your team uses predictably.
  • Employees don't value the coverage they have, or unused amounts reset every year.
  • The cost is starting to decide hiring or pay decisions.

When does a group benefits plan stop making sense for a small business? and Alternatives to group health insurance in Canada cover those options in more depth.

A structural option: insurance for big risks, an HTA for everyday care

Some owners respond to a big renewal by keeping insured coverage for large, unpredictable risks and funding everyday eligible care through a separate account:

A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.

An HTA doesn't make claims or medical trend disappear, and it doesn't replace drug or disability insurance. What it changes is how the everyday portion is funded: the employer sets the amount, and unused balances are designed to carry forward instead of resetting. People often search "HSA" for this kind of account. Zemma's product is an HTA, not an HSA. See Is a Health Trust Account (HTA) an alternative at benefits renewal? and HTA vs group benefits for Canadian small businesses.

For tax treatment, start with the CRA's public pages on employer-paid medical expenses and health plans and What CRA rules apply to employer health accounts in Canada?, and confirm the details with your accountant.

Big renewal checklist

Before you accept a 15% or 20%+ increase:

  • Have we compared our number to the *published 2026 outlooks* (and understood what each measures)?
  • Have we asked for the *full renewal report*, not just the rate letter?
  • Do we know *which benefit lines* drove the increase?
  • Do we know whether a *large claim* is involved, and how much of it is *pooled*?
  • Have we asked what *trend assumption* and *pooling charge* the insurer used?
  • Has *who's on the plan* changed in a way that explains part of it?
  • Did we change *plan design* this year?
  • Has our advisor given us *options* (negotiate, redesign, market the plan)?
  • Is this a *one-off* or a *pattern* across renewals?
  • If everyday care is the real cost, have we priced *insurance + HTA* as a structural option?
  • Do we have enough time before the *renewal deadline* to act?
  • Have we avoided treating any outlook, including this guide, as a *quote* or as legal or tax advice?

About Zemma

Zemma is a benefits platform for Canadian solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time benefits buyers. Zemma's Health Trust Account (HTA) funds everyday care with balances that carry forward, alongside insurance for bigger risks.

Who this is for

  • Owners and office managers searching "is a 20% benefits renewal increase normal," "benefits went up 25% small business," or "huge group benefits increase what to do"
  • Small teams facing a January 1 renewal with a number they didn't expect
  • First-time benefits buyers wondering whether a big jump is typical
  • Brokers and accountants who want a shareable, sourced explainer to walk a client through a big renewal

FAQ

Is a 15% benefits renewal increase normal in Canada?

It can happen, especially in small plans, but it's above Canadian industry outlooks for 2026, which mostly fall around 7–10%. Treat it as a reason to ask for the full renewal report and have your advisor explain what drove it.

Is a 20% or 25% group benefits increase normal for a small business?

It's not typical, but small plans can swing that much after a large claim, a change in who's on the plan, or higher pooling or trend charges. Don't accept it without understanding each driver and reviewing your options.

Why did my benefits renewal go up so much?

Common causes are a large claim, experience rating, pooling charges, trend assumptions, demographic changes, plan design changes, and admin or retention charges. The full renewal report, not just the letter, shows which ones apply.

What should I do if my group benefits renewal is too high?

Ask for the full renewal report, understand how large claims are pooled, ask your advisor for options such as negotiating, redesigning, or marketing the plan, compare structures, and decide before the renewal deadline.

Can I negotiate a big benefits renewal increase?

Often, yes. Your broker or advisor can question the assumptions behind the renewal, ask for adjustments, or get quotes from other insurers. Starting early gives you more room.

When is a big renewal a sign to change my plan's structure?

When above-market increases repeat across renewals, most of your cost is predictable everyday care, employees don't value the coverage, or the cost is shaping hiring decisions. That's when it's worth comparing structures, not just prices.

What is a Health Trust Account (HTA)?

A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.

If your renewal came in at 15% or more, start with the full report and the checklist above, and bring both to your broker. If you want to see how an HTA could sit beside your insurance for everyday care, book a 20-minute intro with Richard or take a look at how Zemma works. We work alongside your broker and accountant.

Related questions

Not legal, tax, or medical advice. Industry figures are third-party outlooks, attributed and dated above; they aren't quotes, and your renewal depends on your own plan. Confirm every detail with your broker or advisor and your accountant. Figures last reviewed: Oct 21, 2026. Last updated: Oct 21, 2026. Last updated: Oct 21, 2026.