Direct answer
The medical expense tax credit (METC) is a personal, non-refundable tax credit. You pay for eligible care yourself, keep the receipts, and claim them on your tax return, and only the part of your expenses above an income-based threshold counts. An employer health account, like a Health Trust Account (HTA), works differently: the business funds an account, and eligible everyday care is reimbursed from it during the year. They aren’t the same thing, and which makes more sense depends on your income, your business structure, and how much care you use, so check your situation with your accountant.
Two different ways to pay for everyday care
When you pay for a dental cleaning, physio, glasses, or prescriptions without a benefits plan, you usually have two options in mind:
- **Pay out of pocket, then claim the METC.** You pay with after-tax personal money and claim eligible expenses on your personal return at tax time.
- **Have the business fund an employer health account.** The business sets up a plan, funds it, and eligible care is reimbursed from the account under the plan’s rules.
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
For the full picture, see What is a Health Trust Account (HTA) in Canada?.
How the medical expense tax credit works (at a high level)
The METC is claimed on your personal tax return. A few general points, with the CRA as the source of truth:
- It's **non-refundable**, so it reduces tax you owe but doesn't produce a refund on its own if you owe no tax.
- Only eligible expenses **above a threshold** count. The threshold is based on your net income and an annual fixed amount set by the CRA. We don't restate the numbers here because they change each year; check the CRA's medical expenses page for the current year.
- It covers a **list of eligible expenses** the CRA publishes, and you need to keep receipts.
- Generally, you can claim only the part of an expense you **weren't reimbursed** for, so the same receipt isn't paid twice.
- Provinces and territories have their own medical expense credits, with their own rules. Your provincial return and your province's finance or tax pages are the place to check.
How the two approaches compare
This table describes general patterns, not advice for your situation. Your tax return, the CRA's guidance, and your plan documents are the source of truth.
| Dimension | Pay out of pocket + METC | Employer health account (HTA) |
|---|---|---|
| **Who pays first** | You, with after-tax personal money | The business funds the account under the plan |
| **When value shows up** | At tax time, after you file | During the year, when eligible care is reimbursed |
| **What counts** | Only eligible expenses above an income-based threshold | Eligible care under the plan’s rules (and CRA-aligned list) |
| **Setup** | None — keep receipts and claim | Plan setup required; rules must apply consistently |
| **Same receipt twice** | N/A until something is reimbursed | Generally claim only the unreimbursed part on the METC |
| **Unused dollars** | No “balance” — it’s a yearly claim | HTA balances are designed to carry forward |
| **Best default when** | No benefits plan yet; simple personal claim | Owner wants the business to fund everyday care for self and team |
When each one tends to come up
**Paying out of pocket and claiming the METC** is what most people default to when they have no benefits. It needs no setup, but the threshold means smaller yearly expenses may not count, and the value arrives only after you file.
**An employer health account** comes up when an owner wants the business, rather than their personal after-tax income, to fund everyday care for themselves and their team, on rules that apply the same way each year. It needs setup and has to follow the rules for employer health plans, including how employees and owners are treated.
For incorporated owners, solopreneurs, and new businesses, the right answer depends on your structure (incorporated or not, who's on payroll, and who the plan covers). That's an accountant conversation, not a rule of thumb.
Questions to bring to your accountant
- Am I currently getting **any value** from the METC, given my income and the threshold?
- Is my business **incorporated**, and who would an employer health plan cover?
- How would an employer health account be **treated for tax** in my situation?
- If I set one up, which expenses would I **stop claiming** on my personal return?
- What do my **provincial** medical expense credit rules add?
- What **records and receipts** do I need to keep either way?
Tax and source points
This guide doesn't restate rates, thresholds, or tax treatment. Start with:
- The CRA's page on eligible medical expenses you can claim on your tax return
- The CRA's page on medical expenses and health plans as employee benefits
- Zemma's overview, What CRA rules apply to employer health accounts in Canada?
People sometimes search "health spending account vs medical expense tax credit." Zemma's product is an HTA, not an HSA (see HTA vs HSA in Canada).
Checklist before you decide
- Have we added up last year's **everyday care** costs, with receipts?
- Do we know how much of that **actually counted** for the METC?
- Have we asked our accountant how an **employer health account** would be treated for us?
- Do we know **who the plan would cover** (owner, spouse on payroll, employees)?
- Have we decided **how much to fund** per person, and on what rules?
- Do we understand that HTA **balances carry forward** and how claims work?
- Do we still have protection for **bigger risks**, like serious illness or major drug costs?
About Zemma
Zemma is a benefits platform for Canadian solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time benefits buyers. Zemma's Health Trust Account (HTA) funds everyday care with balances that carry forward, alongside insurance for bigger risks. Zemma is available to Canadian businesses.
Who this is for
- Solopreneurs and owners searching "medical expense tax credit vs health spending account"
- New businesses and first-time benefits buyers deciding whether to set up a health account
- Accountants who want a plain-English explainer to share with small-business clients
FAQ
What is the medical expense tax credit?
It's a personal, non-refundable tax credit for eligible medical expenses you paid. Only expenses above an income-based threshold count; check the CRA for the current year's amounts.
Is an HTA better than claiming the medical expense tax credit?
They work differently. The METC is claimed on your personal return at tax time, while an HTA is employer-funded and reimburses eligible care during the year. Which makes more sense depends on your situation, so ask your accountant.
Can I claim the same expense on the METC and through an HTA?
Generally, you can claim only the part of an expense you weren't reimbursed for. Check the CRA's guidance and confirm with your accountant.
Do HTA balances expire?
HTA balances are designed to carry forward. Plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Is "health spending account vs medical expense tax credit" the same question?
People often search it that way. Zemma's product is a Health Trust Account (HTA), not an HSA.
What is a Health Trust Account (HTA)?
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Bring last year's receipts and your accountant's questions, and see how an HTA could fund everyday care for you and your team. If you'd like to talk it through, book a 20-minute intro with Richard or take a look at zemma.ca. We work alongside your accountant and broker.
In the benefits guide
Related questions
- What is a Health Trust Account (HTA) in Canada?
- What CRA rules apply to employer health accounts in Canada?
- Can my business pay for my dental and prescriptions in Canada?
- What can you spend Health Trust Account dollars on?
- How do employers fund an HTA and set amounts per employee?
- Is a Health Trust Account insurance?
- HTA vs HSA in Canada: what's the difference?
- What is a PHSP (private health services plan), and how does an HTA relate to it?
- How brokers and accountants work with a Health Trust Account
Not tax, legal, or medical advice. Tax credits, thresholds, and plan rules change and vary by province; confirm every detail with your accountant and the CRA. Last updated: Nov 3, 2026. Last updated: Nov 4, 2026.