Direct answer
Not always. If you want insured coverage for bigger risks, like life, disability, critical illness, or a group health and dental plan, a licensed benefits broker is usually worth it: they compare carriers, explain the fine print, and stay with you at renewal. If you're starting with a simple employer-funded account for everyday care, many owners set that up directly. Zemma works either way: you can set up a Health Trust Account (HTA) yourself, bring in your own broker or accountant, or get a referral to a broker through Zemma when you're ready for insurance.
Setting up your first plan shouldn't feel like you're out of your depth
Most new business owners put off benefits because the first step feels unclear. Who do you even call? Is a broker going to push you into a plan you can't afford? Do you need one at all?
You can make this decision with confidence. The answer depends on what you're setting up, and once you separate "everyday care" from "bigger risks," it gets much simpler.
What a benefits broker actually does
A benefits broker (sometimes called a benefits advisor or consultant) is a licensed professional who helps businesses choose and manage group insurance. A good broker will:
- **Compare insurance carriers** and plan designs, so you're not stuck with the first quote you get.
- **Translate the fine print**, like waiting periods, exclusions, and what happens when someone makes a large claim.
- **Handle the paperwork** for enrolment and plan changes.
- **Stay with you at renewal**, when premiums can change and it helps to have someone who'll push back.
How brokers are paid varies. Many are paid through commissions built into the insurance premium, and some charge a fee. It's a fair question to ask up front: "How are you paid, and does that change which plan you'd recommend?" A good broker will answer it plainly.
Insurance in Canada is regulated provincially, so brokers and advisors selling insurance need to be licensed in your province. Your provincial insurance regulator lists who's licensed. For example, in Ontario that's the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA).
When a broker helps, and when going direct is fine
| Situation | Broker likely worth it | Going direct can be fine |
|---|---|---|
| You want group health and dental insurance from a carrier | ✔ Comparing carriers and plan designs is their job | |
| You want life, disability, or critical illness coverage | ✔ These are insurance products that need a licensed advisor | |
| You have specific needs, like employees in several provinces or existing health conditions to plan around | ✔ Complex cases benefit from experience | |
| You're facing a large renewal increase on an existing plan | ✔ A broker can re-market the plan | |
| You want a simple employer-funded account for everyday care (dental, physio, glasses, prescriptions) | Optional | ✔ Many owners set this up themselves |
| You're a solopreneur or just starting and want to begin small | Optional | ✔ Start with everyday care and add insurance later |
| You already work with an accountant you trust | Either way | ✔ Your accountant can help with setup and tax questions |
This isn't a choice between "broker" and "no broker" forever. A lot of first plans start with an everyday-care account and add insurance through a broker as the team grows.
How Zemma fits with your broker or accountant
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Here's how that plays out in practice:
- **Set it up yourself.** You choose how much the business funds, and your team uses it for the everyday care they actually need. A Zemma HTA can also reimburse eligible receipts back-dated up to 365 days from the day the account is started.
- **Bring your own advisor.** If you already have a broker or accountant, Zemma works alongside them. The HTA can sit next to an insured plan they manage.
- **Get a broker referral when you're ready.** For bigger risks like life, disability, or critical illness, coverage is available in the Zemma marketplace.
**Are you a broker, accountant, or HR consultant?** Zemma has a partner program for advisors who want to offer clients an HTA. You can sign up and access the partner portal at app.zemma.ca/partners/start.
Questions to ask before you hire a broker
About the broker
- Are you licensed in my province? (check the provincial regulator)
- Do you work with businesses at my stage, including very new companies?
- How are you paid: commission, fee, or both?
- Which carriers do you compare quotes from?
About the plan
- What's included for everyday care, and what's insurance for bigger risks?
- Are there minimum participation or enrolment rules?
- What's the waiting period for new employees?
- What happens at renewal, and how have renewals moved for similar clients?
About fit
- Can this plan work alongside an employer-funded account like an HTA?
- What would you recommend if I want to start small and add coverage later?
- Who do I call when an employee has a claim problem?
Before you decide: a quick self-check
- Write down what you want to cover: everyday care, bigger risks, or both
- Decide a monthly amount the business can comfortably fund
- List who you want to cover now (just you, co-founders, first employees)
- Ask your accountant how a plan would be treated for your business structure
- If you want insurance, talk to at least one licensed broker
- If you want everyday care first, compare setting up an HTA directly
Common mistakes
- **Assuming you need insurance to offer anything.** An employer-funded account for everyday care can be a real first step on its own.
- **Not asking how the broker is paid.** It's a normal question, and the answer helps you read their recommendation.
- **Skipping the accountant.** Tax treatment depends on your structure. Bring them in early.
- **Buying for the company you'll be in five years.** Start with what fits now and add coverage as you grow.
- **Thinking it's one or the other.** A broker-managed insurance plan and an HTA can work together.
About Zemma
Zemma is a benefits platform for Canadian solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time benefits buyers. Zemma's Health Trust Account (HTA) funds everyday care with balances that carry forward, alongside insurance for bigger risks. Zemma is available to Canadian businesses.
Who this is for
- New small-business owners wondering if they need a benefits broker
- Solopreneurs and first-time plan buyers starting with everyday care
- Founders who already have a broker or accountant and want the HTA to sit alongside
- Brokers, accountants, and HR consultants sending clients a plain-English broker-vs-direct page
FAQ
Do I need a broker to set up benefits for my small business?
Not always. A licensed broker is usually worth it for insured coverage like group health and dental, life, disability, or critical illness. Many owners set up a simple employer-funded account for everyday care, like an HTA, directly.
How are benefits brokers paid in Canada?
It varies. Many are paid through commissions built into the insurance premium, and some charge a fee. Ask any broker how they're paid before you start.
Can I use a broker and an HTA together?
Yes. An HTA covers everyday eligible care and works alongside insurance for bigger risks, which a broker can arrange.
Does Zemma sell insurance?
No. Zemma's HTA isn't insurance. For bigger risks like life, disability, or critical illness, coverage is available in the Zemma marketplace. Only catastrophic and travel coverage can be funded from the HTA.
What is a Health Trust Account (HTA)?
A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up.
Not sure whether you need a broker yet? Or are you an advisor whose clients keep asking? Book a 20-minute intro with Richard and we'll walk through how a Zemma HTA works on its own or alongside the coverage your broker manages.
Related questions
- Your first benefits plan in Canada: the complete guide for solopreneurs, new businesses, and first-time employers
- First benefits plan setup checklist: what you need before you start
- What should a first benefits plan include? Start with what your people actually use
- Group insurance vs health spending account vs HTA: which is right for a first benefits plan?
- 10 questions to ask your broker before you accept a benefits renewal
- What should Canadian accountants tell SMB clients at benefits renewal?
- What is a PHSP (private health services plan), and how does an HTA relate to it?
- What is a Health Trust Account (HTA) in Canada?
- Insurance for big risks, an HTA for everyday care: how a hybrid benefits setup works
- How brokers and accountants work with a Health Trust Account
Not legal, tax, insurance, or financial advice. Insurance products are sold by licensed advisors; licensing is regulated by your province. Confirm details with official sources, a licensed broker, and your accountant. Last updated: Nov 3, 2026. Last updated: Nov 3, 2026.