Should I give my first employee cash instead of health benefits?

Last reviewed: November 20, 2026

Reviewed by Kevin Kliman, licensed insurance broker

Direct answer

You can give a first employee cash instead of health benefits, and many small businesses start that way. Extra pay or a health allowance paid as wages is employment income, with income tax, Canada Pension Plan, and Employment Insurance. A reimbursement of medical bills outside a private health services plan is the CRA’s starting point for a taxable benefit, and cash still does not do the job of a plan the person can use for care.

The instinct is kind. You would rather hand someone money than wrestle a booklet. The person still has to turn that money into a dentist visit after tax, and a big bill does not get smaller because the raise was labelled “for health.”

Owners usually mean one of three things: a higher salary, a monthly allowance on top of wages, or paying a health bill from the business when someone asks. The first two are pay. CRA guide T4001 is the payroll guide for deductions. Guide T4130 is the guide for taxable benefits and allowances. Read both with your accountant before you put a health allowance on a pay stub and hope the label changes the tax.

The third one, paying the bill informally, is the one to slow down on. The CRA says that if you pay or reimburse an employee’s medical expenses, the amount is generally a taxable benefit, unless it is paid under a private health services plan. A plan has to meet the CRA’s conditions, including the 90% test and being in the nature of insurance. A casual e-transfer is not that plan.

Quebec does not follow the federal exception in the same way. Revenu Québec says an employer’s contribution to a private health services plan is a taxable benefit for Quebec tax, reported in boxes A and J of the RL-1. A raise is taxable in every province. A qualifying plan can still be the kinder structure federally, and in Quebec you still report the employer contribution. Zemma does not operate in Quebec.

What you might doWhat it usually isWhat people feel
A higher salaryEmployment income, with tax, CPP, and EISimple, and gone once it is spent
A monthly health allowance on payrollAlso employment income, unless a real plan says otherwiseA label, not coverage
Paying a receipt with no planGenerally a taxable benefit under the CRA payroll pageHelpful once, messy at T4 time
A written plan for everyday careA private health services plan, if it qualifiesCare they can see, with rules you can explain

How Zemma does it

Zemma is a licensed health benefits brokerage, not an insurer and not a bank. The Health Trust Account is for everyday eligible care. The platform fee is $10 per person a month, plus whatever you put in their HTA. Balances are designed to carry forward. Optional catastrophic and travel coverage can be funded from the HTA if chosen, and it is underwritten by licensed insurers.

A Health Trust Account (HTA) is Zemma's employer-funded health account. Your company funds one monthly amount; people spend it on any CRA-approved care, like dental, physio, glasses, and prescriptions; balances are never forfeited at year end. Employees can put part of it toward catastrophic and travel insurance if they want. The HTA isn't insurance, and plan design and eligibility depend on how it's set up. Zemma does not operate in Quebec. This is not tax, legal, or medical advice.

Sign up on zemma.ca. The account opens at app.zemma.ca/start.

FAQ

Is a health allowance tax-free if I call it that?

Do not assume so. An allowance paid as cash is generally employment income. Guide T4130 is the CRA’s guide to allowances and benefits. The non-taxable path people mean is a private health services plan, and it has conditions.

Can I reimburse a dental bill and skip the plan?

The CRA’s starting point is that a reimbursement outside a private health services plan is a taxable benefit. Talk to your accountant before you pay personal health costs from the business account.

Does cash protect someone if a large bill shows up?

Only to the extent they saved it. A raise does not pay a hospital bill or a month of prescriptions by itself. Insurance is the tool for large, uncertain costs. An account is the tool for everyday care.

Related answers

Zemma Health Inc., in Collingwood, Ontario, is not an insurance company and not a bank. Optional catastrophic and travel coverage, funded from the HTA, is underwritten by licensed insurers. Zemma administers the Health Trust Account and the platform. This is not tax, legal, or medical advice. Plan design, eligibility, and tax treatment depend on how the plan is set up. Last updated: November 20, 2026.